Abigail Newcombe

Which of your cases makes you proudest of the result?

The cases that I am the proudest of the result are the ones in which a strong position was taken at the beginning, on either damages and liability, and a favourable settlement/judgment is reached for our insured. The most rewarding part of this work is being able to assist our insureds through a very difficult process and it means a great deal to me when they are pleased with the end result.

What do you think the most important factor is in resolving a file?

I have found that respectful communication regarding the file on its merits is the most important factor in coming to a resolution. Our justice system is adversarial by nature and I vigorously defend each one of my clients. However, what normally facilitates resolution is frank and honest conversations with opposing counsel regarding each parties interests. These conversations allow both parties to see the bigger picture of the file and negotiate a fair resolution.

What’s the most valuable lesson that your professional experience has taught you?

You can never be too prepared. Many of the make or break details for a file are buried in medical documents or start as a benign comment during an Examination for Discovery. Preparation allows for effective, organized and persuasive advocacy that leads to the best results for the client and for the insured.


Abigail maintains a broad insurance litigation practice. She has experience acting for clients on range of litigation matters, including personal injury, occupier’s liability, professional negligence and property damage. Prior to joining Marta Watson LLP as an associate in 2023, she practiced in-house at one of Canada’s largest property and casualty insurers.

Abigail graduated from the Schulich School of Law at Dalhousie University in 2020 and was called to the bar in 2021. She is a member of the Canadian Bar Association, the Ontario Bar Association and Canadian Defence Lawyers.

In her spare time, Abigail enjoys attending workout classes, trying new coffee shops and reading.

Education and Credentials

  • Called to the Ontario Bar, 2021
  • J.D., Schulich School of Law at Dalhousie University, 2020
  • Bachelor of Arts, Honours, Acadia University, 2017

Abigail Newcombe

Legal Assistant
Heather Gordon

Law Clerk
Alethia Fleuelling